Reddit's Moderation Crisis: Power, Censorship, and Silenced Voices

Proudly written by Callan Hansen

April 8th, 2025

I’m writing this because I’ve witnessed how centralized, unchecked moderation power can silence voices, twist narratives, and erase a user’s ability to contribute—all without a shred of accountability.

Let’s be clear: subreddit moderators aren’t elected. They aren’t vetted. They aren’t held to any meaningful standard. The first person to claim a subreddit becomes its unelected ruler, free to curate, delete, censor, and ban at will. Reddit hands them this power with no oversight—meaning a few anonymous individuals can hold immense control over entire communities.​ It’s not democracy—it’s digital authoritarianism.

Now, this isn’t to say every moderator abuses their position. Many are volunteers who genuinely care about fostering healthy communities and keeping out spam. But the problem lies in the structure itself—there are no guardrails, no accountability mechanisms in place when that power is misused. And when it is, users have virtually no recourse.

My Experience

​I felt this firsthand when I was banned from two niche communities centered on psychedelics. I wasn’t trolling or spamming—I was sharing blog posts about personal experiences and philosophy, ideas I believed enriched the conversation. Yet my posts were removed without a word, my voice erased with no way to appeal. It wasn’t about breaking rules; it was about control, plain and simple.

​And I’m far from alone. In a feedback thread from a psychedelic community, a moderator asked for suggestions to improve the space—a rare chance for users to speak up. One user did, bravely calling out the unchecked power of moderators. Their words were a plea for fairness, for a system that values the community over the whims of a few. But what happened? Their comment was deleted. The moderator replied, “People aren’t banned unless they break the rules”—then banned the user moments later accusing them of “ban evasion” for trying to reply. The exchange, captured below, lays bare the hypocrisy and the silencing at the heart of Reddit’s moderation system.

To be fair, moderation is a difficult job. Communities can be chaotic, and moderators often have to make quick calls in an environment that doesn’t reward transparency. But that’s exactly why structure matters. Power without transparency inevitably leads to abuse—even if unintentionally.

​This is a systemic failure. Reddit shapes discourse. It sets the stage for how entire movements, like psychedelics, are perceived. When a handful of unaccountable users decide what’s “allowed,” they’re not just moderating—they’re controlling the narrative. This is the same kind of control that’s kept psychedelics demonized for decades, the same gatekeeping that stifles progress. It’s not just governments or corporations doing this—it’s happening right here, in online spaces we thought were free. If we can’t speak openly about transformative ideas like psychedelics, what hope do we have for real change?

Reddit Must Change—Now

Reddit must overhaul its moderation system from the ground up. We need transparency: a clear appeals process for bans and censorship, with moderators held accountable for their actions. We need a model that prioritizes free expression, where users can share ideas without fear of being silenced by a mod who simply disagrees. Solutions like optional verified accounts—linked to real identification but protected by strict privacy safeguards—could help curb spam and abuse while preserving open dialogue.

​Right now, Reddit’s system empowers random individuals with unchecked authority. That’s not a community—it’s a fiefdom. If we want psychedelics, or any meaningful topic, to be discussed honestly, the platforms we rely on must embody that same honesty. Until Reddit changes, the narrative will remain controlled, and voices like mine—voices like that user who dared to speak up—will be silenced. We deserve better. Let’s demand it.